top of page
Apartment Building

Publications

Cost to Set Aside a Statutory Demand in NSW

Writer: John Merlo
John Merlo
13 minutes ago
16 min read

Key Takeaways

  • Fighting a statutory demand in NSW costs $3,949 in court fees at the corporate rate (or $1,443 for a company with turnover under $200,000) before a lawyer does any work, so whether it is worth doing turns on the size of the debt: on a demand near the $4,000 minimum it usually is not, and on a large one it usually is.

  • The real exposure is the costs order. An unsuccessful application normally carries an order that the company pay the creditor’s costs, and on a contested application that order will usually dwarf the filing fee.

  • Whether the expense is justified is a ratio, not a principle: the size of the demand against the cost of a contested application and the cost of being wound up.

  • Cost scales with the number of grounds and the quality of the evidence, not with the size of the debt. A $6,000 demand can generate the same bill as a $600,000 one.

  • If the application succeeds the company usually recovers costs, but on the ordinary basis, so a win still leaves a gap between what you spend and what you recover.


This article is about the money: the arithmetic of whether fighting is worth it. It assumes you have already read our guide to statutory demands in NSW construction and know what a demand is, or that you are working through the first 48 hours after service. Where the pay-or-fight decision itself is covered, this article does not repeat it — it prices it.





Why the filing fee is the smallest number in the decision

A company applies to set aside a statutory demand under s 459G of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act). In New South Wales that application is commenced in the Supreme Court, and it attracts the court’s originating process fee. The fee is fixed, published and indexed, and it does not move with the size of the demand.


The current schedule, as at 1 July 2026, sets the fee as follows:

Item

Individual

Corporation

Originating process — commencing the application

$1,443

$3,949

Notice of motion or interlocutory process (e.g. a security for costs or strike-out motion)

$798

$1,598

Reissue of a document due to party error

$57

$114


Only a company can apply under s 459G, so the corporate rate is the default: $3,949 to file, before a lawyer has done any work. A company that satisfies a registrar that its turnover in the previous financial year was under $200,000 (or, if newly formed, is likely to be under $200,000 in its first year) pays the individual rate of $1,443 instead, under cl 4(4) of the Civil Procedure Regulation 2017 (NSW). That concession turns on turnover, not hardship. The figure is drawn from the Supreme Court’s filing fees schedule.


Now put that beside the demand. A statutory demand can be issued for a debt at the statutory minimum, which reg 5.4.01AAA of the Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Regulations) prescribes as $4,000. On a demand of that size the filing fee alone is close to the whole debt. On a demand of $400,000 the same $3,949 is a rounding error. The fee is identical in both cases; the decision it forces is completely different. That asymmetry is the entire cost analysis, and it is why an article that answers this question with a lawyer’s hourly rate has answered the least important part of it.


Practice note. The $3,949 is a disbursement, and it is paid at the door. If the application succeeds it forms part of the costs you may recover from the creditor, but you carry it until then, and on the ordinary basis you will not recover all of it.



What the filing fee does and does not cover

The filing fee buys the commencement of the proceeding and nothing else. The application is an originating process in Form 2 under the Supreme Court (Corporations) Rules 1999 (NSW) (Corporations Rules), r 2.2. Rule 2.4A then requires a search of the ASIC records for the plaintiff, carried out no earlier than seven days before filing and no later than the day before the hearing, and either annexed to the affidavit in support or filed or tendered separately. That search is a disbursement and a step, not a court fee, and it is easily left to the last day. Everything else after filing is either a further court fee or professional cost.

A contested application is rarely a single event. If the creditor seeks security for costs, or moves to strike out part of your affidavit, each of those steps is an interlocutory process. The creditor pays the filing fee for its own motion, but every motion adds professional costs on both sides and enlarges the costs order the company faces if it loses. Any motion the company files itself attracts the $1,598 corporate fee. If a document has to be reissued because of an error, that is charged too. Transcript, if the hearing is recorded and you want it, is not a court fee but a disbursement, and it is priced per day.


The court does publish guidelines for the waiver, remission or postponement of fees for parties who cannot pay. The guidelines exist because the fees are real, and they are worth knowing about. But read them with care in this context. A company applying for a fee waiver is telling the court it cannot afford $3,949, at the same time as it is presenting itself as a trading business that disputes the debt rather than one that cannot pay it. Those two positions can be reconciled, but not casually, and a creditor who notices the inconsistency will use it.


There is also a route that avoids the fee entirely, and it is the one people forget: if the application is not made, nothing is filed and nothing is paid. Why that is not a saving is explained below, under what a winding-up costs.



What drives the cost of setting aside a statutory demand

Professional cost in a set-aside application is driven by the shape of the dispute, not by the amount of the debt. Six things move it.


The first is the ground you run: s 459H of the Corporations Act covers a genuine dispute about the existence or amount of the debt, and an offsetting claim. s 459J(1)(a) covers a defect in the demand where substantial injustice will be caused unless the demand is set aside; s 459J(1)(b) is the residual ground that there is some other reason to set the demand aside. Each ground needs its own evidence and its own argument, and running three is not three times the work of running one, but it is close.


In construction, check one point before costing any of this: where the demand is founded on a payment claim that was not answered with a payment schedule, s 15(4) of the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) bars cross-claims and contract defences in proceedings to recover that amount, and that can narrow the genuine dispute available on a set-aside application.


The second is the affidavit. The application must be accompanied by a supporting affidavit, and under s 459G(3) of the Corporations Act the application and the affidavit must be filed and served within the 21 days. The affidavit is where the money goes. At a minimum it must disclose the facts showing a genuine dispute; a bare assertion that the debt is disputed is not enough, and that gap cannot be filled after the 21 days. In practice it should exhibit the contract, the variations, the payment claims and the correspondence, because those documents are the quickest way to show the dispute is real. An affidavit built on assertion rather than facts invites the objection that it is not a supporting affidavit at all. That objection is cheap for the creditor to make and expensive for you to answer.


The third is whether the creditor opposes at all. A demand is sometimes withdrawn once a properly evidenced application is served, because the creditor did not want a hearing and can see the demand will not survive one. That is the cheapest outcome available, and it is often reached before the first return date.


The fourth is interlocutory skirmishing. Security for costs, strike-out, objections to evidence, and applications for leave to rely on material not in the original affidavit each add a fee and a set of submissions.

The fifth is whether the matter runs to a contested hearing. If it does, add preparation, a day in court, and possibly counsel.


The sixth is an appeal, if the losing party takes one. It is the most expensive step on the list and the least predictable.



The costs order if you lose

Costs follow the event, and s 1335(2) of the Corporations Act confirms that the costs of a proceeding under that Act are borne by the party the court directs. If the application is dismissed, the usual order — absent some reason to depart from it — is that the company pay the creditor’s costs of the application. That order is ordinarily for the creditor’s costs on the ordinary basis, which covers its reasonable costs of responding to your affidavit and appearing at the hearing, though not necessarily every dollar it spent.


On a contested application that order can exceed the filing fee several times over, and on a demand near the statutory minimum it can exceed the demand itself. This is the number that should be in the decision, and it is the one nobody quotes.


Indemnity costs are available and may be ordered where, for example, the application should not have been brought, or was pressed after the ground had clearly failed. An application that is genuinely arguable but ultimately unsuccessful will normally attract ordinary costs. One that was hopeless from the start can attract more.


If the parties cannot agree the amount, costs are assessed or, in some cases, fixed by the court as a lump sum. Either way, the order is added to a debt the company still owes.


Warning. A set-aside application is not a free look at the creditor’s case. If it fails, the court has found no genuine dispute, the company ordinarily has only seven days after the application is determined to comply with the demand (s 459F(2)(a)(ii) of the Corporations Act), s 459S prevents it from relying on the same ground to oppose a winding-up application without leave, and a costs order has been added to a debt that still has to be paid. On a small demand, that is frequently a worse position than paying on day one.



Security for costs: the second bill nobody budgets for

There is a further exposure that sits outside the ordinary costs order, and it is specific to companies. Under s 1335(1) of the Corporations Act, where a corporation is the plaintiff in a proceeding, the court may — if it appears by credible testimony that there is reason to believe the corporation will be unable to pay the defendant’s costs if the defendant succeeds in its defence — require sufficient security to be given for those costs and stay all proceedings until the security is given.


In a set-aside application the company is the applicant, and creditors have sought security on that basis. The logic is uncomfortable but real: if the company has not paid the demand and its finances are under strain, the creditor asks how it would pay a costs order. The court has to weigh that against the purpose of the jurisdiction, which is to give a company with a genuine dispute a way out of an unjust demand.


The practical consequence is what matters for budgeting. An order for security means money paid into court, or a bank guarantee, before the application is heard. It is not a costs order you might face later; it is cash out now, on top of what you have already spent, and if you cannot find it the application stalls.


What a winding-up costs, and who pays for it

If the demand is not complied with and not set aside, the company is presumed to be insolvent on a winding-up application under s 459P of the Corporations Act (s 459C(2)(a)), and that presumption is the platform for the application. The mechanics of the presumption and the three-month window are set out in our guide to statutory demands in NSW construction; what matters here is the bill.


The creditor pays the filing fee for that application up front, but if a winding-up order is made the liquidator must, unless the court orders otherwise, reimburse the creditor’s taxed costs out of the company’s property (s 466(2) of the Corporations Act), and those costs rank ahead of other unsecured debts (s 556(1)(b)). The company ultimately pays for its own winding-up. If a liquidator is appointed, the liquidator’s remuneration is paid from the company’s assets, which means it comes out of what would otherwise have been available to creditors and, in a small company, out of whatever the directors were relying on. The company usually stops trading, and its employees are generally let go. The directors lose control of the records.


There is also a personal dimension. A director of a company that trades while insolvent can contravene s 588G of the Corporations Act, and the exposure is not extinguished by the company going into liquidation. That is a separate analysis on a separate clock, and it is the reason a demand addressed to the company is never only the company’s problem. If the deadline has already passed, what happens if the deadline is missed sets out the options that remain.


Paying under pressure is not a clean exit either: a payment to one creditor in the six months ending on the relation-back day, made while the company was insolvent, can be recovered as an unfair preference, subject to the statutory defences. The choice is therefore not simply fight or pay, and the cost of each has to be weighed with that in mind. The preference rules should be considered before any payment is made under pressure.



The five options, and what each one costs

Set out side by side, the money looks like this. Which of them to take is the subject of our guide to whether to pay a statutory demand or fight it; the table prices the choice rather than making it.


Option

What you pay

What you carry

Pay the demand

The debt, immediately

Solvency pressure; a preference risk if the company is later wound up

Negotiate or a payment plan

The debt, spread out

The creditor may still file; the 21 days keep running

Set aside on a genuine dispute (s 459H of the Corporations Act)

$3,949 filing fee, plus professional costs and any interlocutory fees

The creditor’s costs if you lose; security for costs if sought

Set aside on a defect (s 459J)

The same

The same, plus the risk that the defect is curable and a corrected demand follows

Do nothing

Nothing now

The s 459C(2)(a) presumption, a winding-up application, and liquidation


The table makes the point that the filing fee is not the cost of the application. It is the entry price. The cost is the professional work plus the exposure, and the exposure is the larger of the two.



When fighting the demand costs more than paying it

There is a ratio at which a set-aside application stops making commercial sense, and it is not a moral question about whether you are right.


Take a demand for $6,000 founded on an invoice you say was already paid, with the remittance advice in your records. You will probably win. You will spend $3,949 on the filing fee before anyone reads the contract, and a multiple of that on the application itself. If you win you recover costs on the ordinary basis, which usually leaves a gap. If you lose you pay the creditor’s costs as well. The expected value of the application is negative even on a strong case, because the amount at stake is smaller than the cost of establishing it.

Now take the same dispute on a demand for $300,000. The same costs are a small fraction of the exposure, the downside of losing is a costs order you can absorb relative to the debt, and the application is plainly worth it.


The ratio is the whole analysis, and it cuts both ways. Where the demand is large, or where a winding-up would end the business, or where the demand is being used as pressure in a genuine commercial dispute, the cost of the application is the cheapest money in the file. Where the demand is small and the dispute is clear, paying under protest and recovering the money in a separate claim, or negotiating, is often the better trade even though it feels like losing.



How to keep the cost down

Four things reduce the bill, and the first is not optional.


File inside the 21 days, with the affidavit. An application may only be made within the statutory period (s 459G(2) of the Corporations Act), which reg 5.4.01AAA(2)(b) of the Corporations Regulations fixes at 21 days from service, and s 459G(3)(a)–(b) requires the affidavit to be filed and served within it. The period cannot be extended. An application filed on day 22 is not a cheap application; it is not an application at all, and the money spent getting ready is wasted.


Build the evidence before you build the argument. The contract, the variations, the payment schedule, the correspondence and the remittance advices should be assembled and indexed first. An affidavit that exhibits the documents and points to the specific clauses does the work; an affidavit that describes the dispute in general terms invites the objection that costs money to answer.


Run the strongest ground, not every ground. Adding a weak second ground lengthens the affidavit and gives the creditor a target. Supreme Court Practice Note SC Eq 4 para 22 also requires a plaintiff in a statutory demand case to state in its outline, for a genuine dispute case, its understanding of the basis on which the debt is said to be owing and why that basis is disputed; for an offsetting claim, the precise facts giving rise to the claim and how the amount is calculated. That structure is worth building into the affidavit from the start rather than reconstructed later.


Ask the creditor to withdraw, early and in writing, with the evidence attached. A withdrawal before the first return date is the cheapest possible outcome, and a creditor who sees a documented dispute has a reason to take it.


If there is a cross-claim, consider whether it is an offsetting claim under s 459H of the Corporations Act rather than something to be pursued separately. The same facts can support both, and running them in one place is cheaper than running them in two.



How Merlo Law can help

We do not publish a fee schedule for this work, because there is no honest single number. A set-aside application on one documented variation in a small subcontract is a different piece of work from a contested application on five grounds with a security for costs motion attached, and the difference is measured in multiples, not percentages. A fixed price quoted before the demand, the contract and the correspondence have been read would not be a price. It would be a guess.


What we do instead is scope it. At the first conference we read the demand, the contract and the correspondence, identify the grounds that are actually available, and tell you what the application will involve and what it will cost in your matter, before you commit to it. If the ratio does not work, we will tell you that too, including where the better answer is to pay or to negotiate.


If you have been served with a statutory demand in New South Wales, or you are deciding whether to fight one, contact Merlo Law. Our commercial law advice covers the wider exposure, including the personal position of directors.



Key cases

  • David Grant & Co Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation (1995) 184 CLR 265. The 21-day period in s 459G of the Corporations Act is a condition of the court’s jurisdiction. It cannot be extended, and an application filed out of time is invalid however strong the underlying dispute.

  • Eyota Pty Ltd v Hanave Pty Ltd (1994) 12 ACSR 785. Decided under the Corporations Law, the predecessor to the Corporations Act, and applied to its successor provision, s 459H, ever since. A genuine dispute exists where there is a plausible contention requiring investigation. The test is not whether the company will ultimately succeed, and that low threshold is what makes an inexpensive application possible in the right case.

  • Graywinter Properties Pty Ltd v Gas & Fuel Corporation Superannuation Fund (1996) 70 FCR 452. The supporting affidavit must disclose the facts showing a genuine dispute — a bare assertion that the debt is disputed is not enough — and failing that threshold is a jurisdictional impediment that cannot be cured by filing further material after the 21 days. It need not deploy the evidence itself: Sundberg J accepted that facts apparent from correspondence the affidavit verifies may suffice. That is why drafting discipline, not volume, is what the affidavit costs you.



Conclusion

The cost of setting aside a statutory demand in New South Wales is $3,949 to file and whatever the dispute costs after that. In construction, where demands commonly arise from a disputed progress claim or an uncertified variation, that arithmetic is decided by the size of the demand rather than the strength of the dispute. The first number is published and fixed. The second is not, and cannot be, because it depends on how much evidence the dispute needs and how hard the creditor fights.


The decision that matters is not what the application costs. It is what losing it costs, measured against the size of the demand. On a large demand, or one that threatens the business, the application is usually the cheapest option on the table. On a small demand, even a strong case can cost more to prove than it is worth, and the honest advice is to say so.


This article is general information about New South Wales procedure and the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) as at November 2026. It is not legal advice. Court fees are indexed and change each 1 July. Get advice on your own circumstances before acting on a statutory demand.



FAQs

How much does it cost to file a set-aside application in NSW?

The Supreme Court filing fee for the originating process is $3,949 at the corporate rate, as at 1 July 2026. A company whose turnover in the previous financial year was under $200,000 can apply to pay the individual rate of $1,443. That is the court fee only. The professional cost of preparing the application and its supporting affidavit is separate, and so is the fee for any motion the company itself files. A motion brought by the creditor is filed at the creditor’s expense, although the company may end up bearing that cost through a costs order.

Usually. Costs follow the event, so a successful applicant will normally receive an order that the creditor pay its costs on the ordinary basis. The ordinary basis does not cover the whole of your own bill, so a win recovers most but rarely all of what you spent.

Sometimes, and on a small demand it often is. The filing fee alone is close to the whole debt where the demand is near the $4,000 statutory minimum, and even a successful application leaves a shortfall. On a large demand, a winding-up risk, or a demand being used as commercial pressure, the application is usually the cheaper course.

That is the cheapest outcome. If a properly evidenced application is served and the creditor withdraws, the application usually does not proceed to a hearing, and the remaining argument is about costs. A demand is sometimes withdrawn at that point because the creditor did not want a contested hearing.

Generally, yes. Under r 7.1 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), a company may commence and carry on proceedings by a solicitor or by a director (r 7.1(2)(a)), but in the Supreme Court a director may commence only if the director is also a plaintiff (r 7.1(3)), so a company applying to set aside a statutory demand will ordinarily need a solicitor on the record. The process is also unforgiving: the 21-day period cannot be extended, so an error in filing or service ends the application, and the supporting affidavit must disclose the facts showing a genuine dispute, not merely assert one.


This guide is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For advice tailored to your specific circumstances, please contact Merlo Law


Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
Urban Building

Contact Us

Contact us on 1300 110 253 to discuss your matter or complete our online form and we will contact you as soon as possible. 

bottom of page