top of page
Apartment Building

Publications

How QLD Builders Handle Concurrent Delays, EOTs and the Prevention Principle

Writer: John Merlo
John Merlo
9 minutes ago
15 min read

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Statutory notice limits override standard contracts: Under Schedule 1B of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (QBCC Act), builders must submit written EOT claims within 10 business days of discovering the delay, regardless of what HIA or Master Builders standard forms may suggest.

  • Concurrent delays require strategic severing: When an excusable delay (e.g., severe weather) overlaps with a builder-caused delay (e.g., subcontractor abandonment), failing to clearly isolate the excusable portion may expose the builder to liquidated damages.

  • Non-compliance forfeits the extension, not a fine: A builder who fails to claim an EOT in strict compliance with the statutory procedure cannot rely on the extension at all, meaning the original date for practical completion stands and liquidated damages may accrue against the builder.

  • Procedural flaws do not instantly void the contract: While a late EOT notice may invalidate the extension claim itself, statutory protections generally prevent the entire domestic building contract from becoming void or unenforceable.



A week of torrential rain has flooded your site, masking a much deeper resourcing crisis: your critical framing subcontractor has abandoned the job entirely. You are staring down a severe concurrent delay, where a genuine, excusable weather event perfectly overlaps with a non-excusable builder resourcing failure. Your immediate instinct is to package both issues into a single extension of time (EOT) claim to buy the project some breathing room. However, presenting a blended EOT claim to a well-advised homeowner gives them the ammunition to reject the entire extension and aggressively apply liquidated damages against your final progress claims. Surviving this collision of delays requires isolating the excusable event from your subcontractor's disappearance and executing the paperwork before strict statutory time bars extinguish your rights.

 

 

The 10-Business-Day Statutory Trap: Navigating EOT Timelines Under Schedule 1B

The rain is pouring, your phone is ringing out when you call the framer, and the clock is actively ticking on your right to claim an extension. You cannot afford to wait until the weather clears or the subcontractor situation resolves before submitting your paperwork. This section delivers the immediate procedural steps and statutory deadlines you must hit this week to secure your valid EOT claim before the window permanently closes.

 

The Danger of Verbal EOT Agreements with Queensland Homeowners

When extreme weather halts site progress, homeowners often provide verbal assurances, telling the builder to take their time and prioritise safety. Contract administrators frequently rely on these informal texts or conversations to pause the project, choosing not to antagonise a cooperative client with formal legal notices. However, this administrative leniency creates real exposure, because verbal comfort does not pause the strict 10-business-day statutory clock for lodging a formal EOT.

 

Verbal agreements for extensions of time are generally insufficient to protect a Queensland builder under Schedule 1B of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991.

 

Relying on a handshake or a text message leaves the builder vulnerable if the relationship sours months later and the homeowner denies the extension. If the builder then attempts to formalise the delay after the fact, the state regulator, the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC), will view the late claim as non-compliant.

 

In practice, the builders who get burned are rarely the ones being lazy. They are the ones being polite. The homeowner says "don't worry about the rain, take the time you need," and the site supervisor, not wanting to sour a good relationship, treats that text as the end of the matter and skips the formal notice.

 

Where this unravels is at practical completion, when the money is on the table and the homeowner engages a solicitor. A tribunal member weighing that dispute will look first at what was issued in writing and when, not at the tone of the parties' correspondence six months earlier. A friendly text saying "take your time" is unlikely to be read as a waiver of the homeowner's right to liquidated damages.

 

The tactical failure is treating the homeowner's goodwill as a substitute for the notice rather than as a reason the notice will be received without friction. Issue the written EOT anyway, and frame it to the client as routine paperwork rather than a hostile legal step. If a homeowner genuinely intends to grant the time, ask them to confirm it in writing in terms that address the specific days claimed, not a vague blessing to run late.

 

Disentangling Statutory Overrides from Contractual EOT Mechanisms

A generous delay clause in your standard contract is not the safety net most builders assume it to be. Contracts drafted by Master Builders Queensland or similar bodies typically include broad delay provisions that appear to grant significant flexibility, but those provisions operate subordinate to a strict legislative framework. It is worth noting at the outset that the Schedule 1B EOT regime applies to a "regulated contract" — broadly, a domestic building contract above the regulated amount — which captures virtually all residential building work of the kind discussed here.

 

The effectiveness of these standard EOT provisions turns entirely on compliance with Schedule 1B of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld).

 

Under Schedule 1B, standard contractual EOT rights operate subject to the statutory requirements, which are designed as consumer-protection minimums. A builder cannot rely on a contractual EOT term to the extent it is inconsistent with those requirements, so any attempt to rely on a more generous contractual timeframe is unlikely to hold if it contradicts the Act. A commercial lawyer Queensland will typically advise that a builder's right to an EOT is governed first by the statutory grounds, and only secondarily by the contract's standard conditions.

 

Triggering the 10-Day Notice Period Upon Discovering a Delay

The statutory clock for an EOT notice does not begin when the delay concludes; it begins the moment the contractor becomes aware of the cause and extent of the delay. Builders often delay sending their paperwork because they want to understand the full impact of a subcontractor abandoning the site before notifying the owner about the initial rain delay. This hesitation is a critical procedural error.

 

To maintain compliance, builders must submit their extension of time claim in writing within 10 business days as required by section 42 of Schedule 1B to the QBCC Act.

 

Failing to issue the notice within this exact timeframe means the builder loses the statutory right to claim the extension. These rigid procedural deadlines function as severe time bar clauses, stripping away the builder's protection against future liquidated damages simply because the paperwork was lodged on day eleven instead of day ten — subject only to any prevention-principle argument, discussed later in this guide, where the owner's own conduct caused the delay.

 

 

Severing Concurrent Delays: When Excusable Events Meet Subcontractor Failures

If you take one thing from this section, take this: claim the wet days, quarantine the framer, and never put both in the same notice. The hardest EOT claims to win are those where your own resourcing failure overlaps directly with a genuine act of God, and a blended claim that mixes unforeseeable weather with the fact your framer walked off the job gives the homeowner's solicitor an easy basis to reject the whole claim for contributory fault. This section explains how to surgically separate the excusable statutory delay from your internal resourcing problems, providing the documentation strategy you need to protect your timeline.

 

Satisfying the 'Unforeseeable' Statutory Test for Excusable Delays

To successfully secure an extension of time builder Queensland, the delay must strictly satisfy the statutory test outlined in section 42(1)(a) of Schedule 1B to the QBCC Act. The legislation mandates that a builder can only claim an extension if the event was not reasonably foreseeable and was beyond their reasonable control.

 

An excusable delay under Queensland's domestic building framework is strictly defined as an event that is unforeseeable and entirely beyond the builder's reasonable control.

 

When applying this test to concurrent delays, a severe weather event typically satisfies the statutory requirement for an excusable delay. Conversely, a subcontractor abandoning the site, or a subcontractor insolvency mid-project, is often viewed as a commercial risk that falls within the builder's control. If a contract administrator fails to distinguish between these two distinct events, they risk having the entire delay period classified as a non-excusable resourcing failure.

 

Drafting EOT Claims to Isolate Non-Excusable Trade Delays

Drafting EOT claims in concurrent delay scenarios requires strict evidentiary discipline to separate the excusable event from the builder's internal failures. If you explicitly reference your subcontractor's abandonment in the same formal notice as the weather event, the homeowner may seize upon this admission to argue that the weather was immaterial to the actual progress of the works.

 

Isolating the weather event in the initial notice can serve as a critical evidence factor, which may prevent the homeowner from weaponising the concurrent delay to invalidate the statutory claim. Strategically severing the claims by submitting a pure, weather-focused EOT for the exact days the site was unworkable is likely to offer better protection against subsequent defect or delay disputes.

 

The drafting discipline here is narrower than most builders expect. Claim the specific dates the site was genuinely unworkable due to weather and stop there. Do not editorialise, do not explain the wider program impact, and above all do not mention the framer in the same document.

 

The quantification problem is the one that trips people up. When a site is both rained out and unstaffed on the same day, the instinct is to claim that day as weather. Resist it. If the framer had already walked before the rain arrived, that day was lost to a resourcing failure regardless of the weather, and claiming it as excusable invites the homeowner to argue the whole notice was constructed in bad faith.

 

The cleaner position is to claim only the days where weather was the operative cause of the site being unworkable, meaning days where work would have proceeded but for the rain. Where the trade was already absent, that day belongs in a separate internal record, not in the EOT notice.

 

Tie each claimed day to an independent source at the point of drafting, not afterwards. Cross-reference the site diary entry against a weather record for the specific site postcode so the claimed dates line up with objectively verifiable rainfall.

 

A notice claiming eight wet days that a homeowner's solicitor can knock down to three using public weather data does more damage than claiming three defensible days from the outset. Before you lodge, assemble a single evidence pack that ties each claimed day to an independent source. At a minimum, this should include: the site diary entries for each claimed date; the Bureau of Meteorology rainfall record for the specific site postcode covering those dates; any site photographs or supervisor notes showing the site was unworkable; and — kept separately, not in the EOT notice — your formal correspondence to the defaulting subcontractor recording the date they left the job. Cross-referencing these at the point of drafting, rather than reconstructing them months later at practical completion, is what makes the claim defensible.

 

 

Leveraging Owner-Caused Delays Under Schedule 1B

Beyond unforeseeable weather, Schedule 1B provides a secondary statutory trigger for an extension: delays caused directly by the building owner. If a homeowner fails to provide site access, or delays critical selections that trigger a variation to the building contract, this owner-caused delay can fundamentally shift the builder's entitlement to an EOT.

 

When an owner-caused delay runs concurrently with a subcontractor's abandonment, it often overrides the builder's resourcing failure for that specific period. Documenting exactly when the owner's delay commenced and ceased allows the contract administrator to trigger this specific statutory ground, potentially carving those days out of any assessment of the builder's internal subcontractor issues.

 

 

Defending Against Liquidated Damages After a Rejected EOT

When a blended EOT claim is rejected, the financial consequences build quickly as the project drifts past the contractual practical completion date. Homeowners will inevitably look to apply daily delay penalties to your final progress claim, weaponising your procedural missteps against you. The numbers add up faster than most builders expect. Liquidated damages in residential contracts are commonly set at a fixed daily rate, so even a modest rate compounds sharply across a disputed delay period: at an illustrative rate of a few hundred dollars per day, a fortnight of rejected delay quickly runs into the thousands, and a month into five figures — deducted straight off your final claim.

 

That is why the difference between claiming three defensible wet days and overreaching for eight is not academic; it is the difference between a deduction you can absorb and one that erases your margin on the job. At this stage, you must carefully navigate the common law defences available to protect your cash flow, while recognising that a technically invalid EOT will not be enforceable and cannot, by itself, extend the date for practical completion.

 

How Concurrent Delays Weaponise Liquidated Damages Clauses

A liquidated damages clause sets a fixed daily amount the builder must pay the homeowner for every day the build runs past the agreed practical completion date, without the homeowner having to prove their actual loss. When a builder submits a concurrent delay claim that fails to isolate the excusable weather event from their subcontractor's failure, the homeowner will often reject the EOT entirely. By establishing that the builder was primarily at fault for the delay, the homeowner attempts to create exposure under the contract's liquidated damages provisions.

 

Liquidated damages in Queensland residential contracts may become payable if a builder fails to secure a valid extension of time for delays that push the project past practical completion.

 

If a homeowner is already offsetting liquidated damages against your final claim on the back of a rejected EOT, the window to protect your position is narrow. Merlo Law can review your notice, your evidence, and the LD deduction, and advise on your exposure before the amount is set. Speak with our building and construction team.

 

A homeowner's ability to successfully deduct liquidated damages in Queensland is likely to depend on whether they can prove the builder lacked a valid statutory or contractual basis for extending the practical completion date.

 

Relying on the Common Law Prevention Principle in Queensland

When an EOT notice is technically flawed or late, builders may need to rely on the common law prevention principle as a defence against the enforcement of liquidated damages.

  • The prevention principle operates as an equitable defence, suggesting that a homeowner cannot enforce liquidated damages if their own actions prevented the builder from reaching practical completion on time.

  • If a homeowner causes a delay (e.g., denying site access or issuing late variations) but the builder fails to submit an EOT within 10 days, courts may consider setting the completion date "at large," potentially rendering the liquidated damages clause unenforceable.

  • However, the enforceability of this defence is highly fact-dependent; a court is likely to heavily scrutinise the interaction between the prevention principle and the builder's failure to comply with the strict notice requirements of Schedule 1B.

  • A builder attempting to rely on this principle must present robust evidence clearly separating the owner-caused delay from any concurrent subcontractor failures.

 

Why an Out-of-Time EOT Is Simply Unenforceable

Warning: Attempting to rely on an EOT that was not issued within the required 10-business-day window is unlikely to succeed. Under section 42 of Schedule 1B to the QBCC Act, a contractor is only entitled to an extension of time if the claim is given to the owner in writing within 10 business days of becoming aware, or when the contractor reasonably ought to have become aware, of the cause and extent of the delay, and the owner approves the claim in writing.

 

Once the owner approves the claim, the builder must also give the owner a signed copy of the approved extension within 5 business days. A claim that misses this window does not attract the extension, meaning the original date for practical completion stands and the builder remains exposed to any liquidated damages that accrue past it. Persistently pressing an invalid EOT against a homeowner also risks drawing broader QBCC scrutiny of the builder's contract administration.

 

 

Managing Procedural Failures and Escalating Dispute Evidence

Even if you miss the 10-day notice window or bungle the drafting of your concurrent delay claim, the situation is rarely fatal to the entire project. The legislation provides specific structural protections that keep your core contractual rights alive. Your focus must immediately shift away from the missed deadline and toward gathering airtight, contemporaneous evidence to prepare for formal dispute escalation and protect your final payment.

 

Why Late EOT Notices Do Not Void the Entire Domestic Building Contract

When a homeowner realises you have missed the 10-day statutory window for an EOT, they may attempt to argue that the entire contract has been breached or is no longer enforceable, justifying their refusal to pay the final claim. However, the QBCC Act contains a specific procedural mechanism designed to prevent minor administrative errors from destroying the builder's broader right to payment.

 

Under section 44 of Schedule 1B to the QBCC Act, a builder’s procedural failure to submit a timely EOT notice does not generally render the overarching domestic building contract void or unenforceable.

 

As stated in the legislation, a failure to comply with a procedural requirement under Schedule 1B in relation to a domestic building contract does not make the contract illegal, void or unenforceable. While the specific extension of time claim may be invalid, the builder's fundamental entitlement to a progress payment for residential building work completed in Queensland remains intact.

 

Evidentiary Burdens for Contract Administrators at Practical Completion

When a delay dispute remains unresolved as the project nears handover, the contract administrator bears the burden of establishing the true date of practical completion in Queensland. If the builder is operating under a Housing Industry Association (HIA) standard form contract, the dispute will often centre on whether the delay was genuinely excusable or merely a subcontractor failure.

 

To defend against liquidated damages, the builder must present contemporaneous evidence that clearly segregates the causes of the delay. Relying solely on memory or informal texts is usually insufficient. The contract administrator should collate site diaries, verified BOM weather reports, and formal notices issued to the defaulting subcontractor. This documentation serves as a critical evidence factor, clearly delineating the days the site was unworkable due to weather versus the days the site was inactive due to the framer's absence.

 

Escalating EOT and Liquidated Damages Conflicts to QCAT

If a homeowner refuses to release the final payment by offsetting unverified liquidated damages against the claim, the builder must prepare to escalate the dispute. In Queensland, entrenched residential building conflicts typically proceed to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT).

 

In a QCAT building dispute, the tribunal will closely examine the builder's adherence to the statutory notice periods and the quality of their evidence regarding concurrent delays. A builder who proactively segregates their excusable delays from their subcontractor's failures in their documentation stands a significantly better chance of defeating the homeowner's claim for delay damages.

 

In practice, a poorly drafted concurrent delay claim tends to hurt the builder twice at the tribunal: once on the merits and again on credibility. When a notice bundles a genuine weather event together with a subcontractor's walk-off, the builder ends up arguing that every lost day was excusable, and that overreach invites the member to discount the entire claim rather than apportion it.

 

The builders who fare better are usually the ones who conceded the resourcing days upfront and claimed only the defensible weather days. That restraint reads as reliability, and a member who trusts one part of the builder's evidence is more inclined to accept the rest of it. The reverse is also true: a claim that visibly overreaches on the excusable days tends to taint the builder's site diaries and correspondence across the whole dispute.

 

 

Conclusion

When severe weather washes out your site while your framing subcontractor simultaneously abandons the job, you are facing the exact scenario where concurrent delays destroy a builder's cash flow. Relying on verbal comfort from a homeowner or assuming standard contract clauses will override the QBCC Act's strict 10-business-day window leaves you exposed to significant liquidated damages. Under section 42 of Schedule 1B to the QBCC Act, a builder cannot rely on a non-compliant, blended delay claim at all, so the original date for practical completion stands and liquidated damages can accrue against the builder.

 

You now understand that surviving a concurrent delay requires surgical precision in your paperwork. You must isolate the excusable statutory delay—such as the unforeseeable weather event—and submit a formal written EOT for those specific days, completely segregating it from your internal subcontractor resourcing failures. While a late notice will invalidate the specific extension, the legislation protects the underlying contract, allowing you to shift focus to gathering contemporaneous evidence for practical completion.

 

Your immediate next step is to review your current project files for any verbal EOT agreements or blended delay claims currently in play. If a concurrent delay is unfolding on one of your sites right now, do not wait until practical completion to get advice. Merlo Law acts for Queensland residential builders on EOT notices, liquidated damages disputes, and QCAT building matters, and can pressure-test your notice against Schedule 1B before day ten closes. Contact our building and construction team to have your EOT position reviewed while it can still be fixed.



FAQs

What is the strict timeframe for claiming an extension of time in Queensland?

Under Schedule 1B of the QBCC Act, a builder must issue a written extension of time claim within 10 business days of becoming aware of the cause and extent of the delay. Failing to meet this statutory deadline typically invalidates the specific EOT claim. This strict timeframe generally overrides any more generous notice periods that may be written into standard industry contracts.

Verbal agreements to extend a timeline are typically insufficient to protect a builder under Queensland’s domestic building legislation. The QBCC Act requires the extension claim to be made in writing within 10 business days. Relying on a verbal assurance may expose the builder to liquidated damages if the homeowner later denies the agreement.

To protect their rights, a builder should strategically sever the excusable delay from the non-excusable delay in their documentation. The builder should formally claim the EOT strictly for the unforeseeable weather event, without blending it with the subcontractor's abandonment in the same notice. This evidentiary separation may reduce the likelihood of the homeowner successfully weaponising the entire delay period against the builder.

Under section 42 of Schedule 1B to the QBCC Act, a builder is only entitled to an extension of time if the claim is given to the owner in writing within 10 business days and the owner approves it in writing. An out-of-time claim does not attract the extension, so the original date for practical completion stands and the builder remains exposed to any liquidated damages accruing past it. Persistently pressing an invalid EOT may also draw broader QBCC scrutiny of the builder's contract administration.

No. While submitting an EOT notice late will likely invalidate the extension itself, section 44 of Schedule 1B to the QBCC Act provides statutory protection for the broader agreement. Unless a contrary intention appears, a failure to comply with a procedural requirement in relation to a domestic building contract does not make the contract illegal, void or unenforceable.

The prevention principle may operate as a defence if the homeowner's own actions (such as denying site access) prevented the builder from reaching practical completion on time. If successfully argued, this principle can sometimes render the liquidated damages clause unenforceable, even if the builder's EOT paperwork was flawed. However, courts are likely to heavily scrutinise the interaction between this common law defence and the strict statutory notice requirements of the QBCC Act.


This guide is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For advice tailored to your specific circumstances, please contact Merlo Law


Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
Urban Building

Contact Us

Contact us on 1300 110 253 to discuss your matter or complete our online form and we will contact you as soon as possible. 

bottom of page