Builder Insolvent Mid-Project NSW: Options for Principals and Subcontractors

Key Takeaways
A builder entering administration or liquidation does not end the project; it splits it into three problems that have to be worked in order — who controls the site, what happens to the money, and which claims outlive the company.
The contract is read before anything is done on site. Whether the principal can take possession and engage others turns on the default, termination and security clauses, not on the fact of insolvency.
The most valuable claims are usually not against the company. For residential work, insurance under the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW) (Home Building Act) responds to non-completion caused by the contractor’s insolvency, and a subcontractor may have a direct statutory route to the principal.
Once an administrator is appointed the administrator controls the company’s business and property, and court proceedings against the company cannot be begun or continued without consent or leave.
Money already paid to the builder for work that was not done, or was defective, is not recovered by having paid it. It is an unsecured claim, admissible to proof only if the circumstances giving rise to it occurred before the relevant date (s 553(1) of the Corporations Act), which is the day the winding up is taken to have begun rather than necessarily the day the administrator was appointed (s 9). Unsecured proofs in a small construction company usually return very little, and no further payment should go to the builder after the appointment without written terms agreed with the administrator.
Introduction
A builder that enters external administration mid-project leaves two parties exposed in different ways. The principal has an incomplete project, a contract it may or may not be able to terminate, and possibly an overpayment. Subcontractors and suppliers have work in the ground and invoices that will not be paid in the ordinary course. Both need to move quickly, and both are usually surprised at how little of the answer lies in the original contract.
This guide sets out the option set for each, in the order the decisions have to be made. It assumes the builder trades through a corporate entity governed by the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) and that the work is residential building work or a construction contract in New South Wales. Where the dispute instead concerns a statutory demand served on a contractor, our guide to statutory demands in NSW construction covers that process separately, and our first 48 hours after service checklist covers the immediate steps.
What insolvency means here, and why the sequence matters
Solvency has a statutory test: can the company pay all its debts as and when they become due and payable (s 95A of the Corporations Act)? A builder can fail that test for months before anyone is appointed, which is why a company search is more informative than a promise.
The two corporate appointments that matter mid-project are administration and winding up. A company may appoint an administrator if the board resolves that, in the opinion of the directors voting, the company is insolvent or likely to become insolvent, and that an administrator should be appointed (s 436A of the Corporations Act). The administrator must then convene a creditors’ meeting to determine whether to appoint a committee of inspection, and that meeting must be held within 8 business days after the administration begins (s 436E).
That eight-day window is the period in which most of the practical damage is done or avoided. Creditors who have not taken advice by the first meeting are usually deciding on a set of facts that has already moved.
The two registers that tell you the truth first
When a builder is said to be in difficulty, the first hour is better spent on primary records than on speculation.
The first is ASIC’s registers. A company search, and ASIC’s published insolvency notices, show whether the entity is in liquidation, administration or receivership, whether an external administrator has been appointed, and when. It also shows the registered address and the officers, which matters because service and correspondence have to go to the right place. A clean search is not a guarantee of solvency, but a search showing an appointment changes the position immediately and completely.
The second is the Personal Property Securities Register maintained under the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) (PPSA). Registration on the register is what perfects most security interests in goods, plant and equipment (s 150). A builder whose plant is already subject to a registered security interest has less available to satisfy an unsecured claim, and a subcontractor considering further supply should know that before it commits. A security interest that is unperfected when an administrator is appointed, or when an order is made or resolution passed to wind the company up, vests in the company (s 267 of the PPSA). That affects whether the supplier can recover the goods at all.
Three further checks are worth making. The first is the contractor licence and any disciplinary history, which NSW Fair Trading and the Building Commission publish on their public registers. The second is the insurance position, because cover is a route to recovery that does not depend on the builder’s balance sheet. The third is the project records, including whether subcontractors have already stopped attending. The purpose is to replace a rumour with a fact, because every decision that follows depends on which fact is true.
Track one: secure the site and the work
The immediate question is who is in possession and who is responsible. On appointment, the administrator has control of the company’s business, property and affairs, may carry on that business, and may terminate or dispose of all or part of it (s 437A of the Corporations Act). The principal does not automatically acquire a right to the site, the materials or the plant.
From the appointment, two restraints govern what anyone can do in court. During the administration, a proceeding against the company or in relation to its property cannot be begun or proceeded with except with the administrator’s written consent or with the leave of the court (s 440D of the Corporations Act), and no enforcement process in relation to the company’s property can be begun or proceeded with except with leave (s 440F). If the company is later wound up, the same restraint applies while it is being wound up (s 471B), meaning any court proceedings require careful procedural assessment before steps are taken.
There is a corresponding limit on the administrator. The administrator must not dispose of property that is subject to a security interest, or property used or occupied by the company but owned by someone else, except in the ordinary course of business, with the secured party’s or owner’s written consent, or with the leave of the court (s 442C of the Corporations Act). That is the provision a subcontractor with retention of title, or a lessor of plant, needs to know about.
The principal’s rights to take possession and engage others therefore depend on the contract: whether the default and termination provisions have been triggered, and what the security arrangements permit. Acting before those provisions are satisfied risks a wrongful termination claim against the principal. The construction contract in NSW should be read before anything is done on site, including before speaking to the administrator. In most disputes that follow an insolvency, the first question asked by a court or an administrator is what the contract permitted the principal to do, and the answer is usually in the default and security provisions rather than in correspondence.
A further restraint operates on the contract itself. When a company comes under administration, a right arising under a contract cannot be enforced against the company for the reason that it has come under administration, or for its financial position while under administration, where the contract provides for the right to arise for that reason (s 451E(1) of the Corporations Act). A termination clause triggered by insolvency or by an administrator’s appointment is therefore stayed for the administration (s 451E(2)), and it does not revive afterwards: the right remains unenforceable indefinitely to the extent the reason for enforcing it is the company’s financial position before the end of the stay period (s 451E(4)). The exceptions are narrow — a contract entered into after the administration began, a kind of contract or right excluded by the regulations or by ministerial declaration, and any right the administrator or a later liquidator consents in writing to enforcing (s 451E(5), (7)).
That is why termination has to be grounded in something other than the insolvency: suspension of the works, a failure to proceed regularly and diligently, expiry or cancellation of the contractor licence, or a failure to provide security the contract requires. Each is a reason that exists independently of the administration, and each is enforceable if the contract says so.
Practice note. Check whether you hold a bank guarantee, and read the conditions attached to calling it, before you speak to the administrator. Calling a guarantee the contract does not permit can be reversed, and the cost of that reversal is yours. |
Track two: protect the money
Two questions decide the money. First, what security does the principal hold — retention, a bank guarantee, a charge — and on what conditions can it be called? Second, is there any payment already made that will not be recovered: an overpayment the principal made to the builder, or a progress payment a subcontractor received that a liquidator may later treat as a preference?
The answer to the second question is governed by proof of debt, not by restitution. In a winding up, all debts payable by and claims against the company, where the circumstances giving rise to them occurred before the relevant date, are admissible to proof against the company (s 553 of the Corporations Act). That includes an overpayment made to the builder, provided the overpayment was made before that date. The date is not the day of the administrator’s appointment: s 9 defines the relevant date as the day on which the winding up is taken, because of Division 1A of Part 5.6, to have begun, so it is fixed by the route into winding up. A payment made after that date falls outside s 553(1) unless s 553(1A) applies. Proving a claim does not get the money back; it puts the principal in a queue behind the secured creditors and, in a small company, behind the costs of the winding up.
Payments already made to other creditors can also be clawed back, which affects how a principal or subcontractor should think about a payment made shortly before the appointment. A transaction is an unfair preference if it results in a creditor receiving from the company, in respect of an unsecured debt, more than the creditor would receive on a proof in the winding up (s 588FA of the Corporations Act), and an insolvent transaction is voidable if it was entered into during the six months ending on the relation-back day, or after that day but on or before the day the winding up began (s 588FE(2)).
For subcontractors the priority is different. The claim is against whoever is in a position to pay — the head contractor, the principal where the statute permits, or an insurer — and each route has its own notice requirements and periods, dealt with below.
One further restraint is worth knowing before resisting a request for records or plant. The court may require a person who is an officer, employee, agent, trustee or receiver of the company to pay, deliver, convey, surrender or transfer to the liquidator any money, property of the company or books in that person’s hands to which the company is prima facie entitled (s 483 of the Corporations Act). Continuing to hold company property after a demand is not a neutral position.
Warning. Do not assume that continuing to supply the administrator is unsecured. A debt the administrator incurs in performing the administrator’s functions, whether for services rendered, goods bought, or property hired, leased, used or occupied, is the administrator’s personal liability (s 443A(1) of the Corporations Act), and that liability applies despite any agreement to the contrary in the supply terms (s 443A(2)). It is supported by an indemnity out of the company’s property that has priority over the company’s unsecured debts (s 443E), and that priority is preserved if the company later moves into liquidation (s 556(1)(a), (c)). What the protection does not reach is pre-appointment arrears, or supplies made after the administration ends, when the administrator is no longer incurring the debt. Get the administrator’s written agreement and purchase order before work resumes. |
Track three: the claims that survive
The claims that outlive the company are often the most valuable, because they are not claims against the company. Four are worth identifying in the first week.
Route | Who can use it | Effect of the administration | First step |
Contract security or bank guarantee | Principal | Enforcement is restrained (s 440F of the Corporations Act); the guarantee is called outside the company | Read the guarantee conditions before calling it |
HBCF insurance (residential work) | Owner of residential work; a developer is excluded (s 99(2) of the Home Building Act) | Not affected — the claim is against the policy, not the company. Minimum cover $340,000 per dwelling (cl 45 of the Home Building Regulation 2014 (NSW) (Home Building Regulation)) | Locate the certificate of insurance |
Adjudication under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) (SOP Act) | Contractor or subcontractor with a payment claim | Runs during administration (enforcing a certificate against the company needs consent or leave under s 440D of the Corporations Act); once in liquidation, a company cannot pursue claims as claimant (s 32B of the SOP Act) and claims against it are stayed without leave (ss 471B, 500(2) of the Corporations Act) | Serve the payment claim before any liquidation, and check whether a payment schedule was given |
Notice under the Contractors Debts Act 1997 (NSW) (Contractors Debts Act) | Subcontractor owed by a defaulting contractor | Reaches money the principal still holds | Certify the debt (s 7 of the Contractors Debts Act), then serve the notice (s 8) |
Director guarantee, or s 588G of the Corporations Act | Creditor holding a guarantee; the company | A guarantee is unaffected; insolvent trading needs a separate claim | Read the credit application for a guarantee |
Insurance: the Home Building Act route, and why commercial principals have none
For residential building work, the Home Building Act requires a complying contract of insurance to be in force, in the name of the person who contracted to do the work, before that work is done and before any payment is demanded or received (s 92). The insurance required by s 92 must insure the person on whose behalf the work is being done against the risk of loss resulting from non-completion of the work because of the insolvency, death or disappearance of the contractor, and against being unable, because of that insolvency, to have the contractor rectify a breach of a statutory warranty or to recover compensation for such a breach (s 99(1)).
For the owner of residential work, this is the point of the whole exercise: the event being lived through — the contractor becoming insolvent mid-project — is the insured event under the Home Building Compensation Fund (HBCF) in NSW, and the home building compensation claim is against a policy the builder was required by statute to hold rather than against the builder’s assets. The amount is not open-ended: the contract of insurance must provide cover of at least $340,000 in relation to each dwelling, for construction period and warranty period contracts alike (s 102(3) of the Home Building Act; cl 45 of the Home Building Regulation).
The statutory warranties themselves are implied into every contract to do residential building work: due care and skill and compliance with the plans and specifications, materials good and suitable, compliance with the law, due diligence and completion within the time stipulated, a dwelling reasonably fit for occupation, and fitness for a specified purpose or result where that purpose was made known (s 18B(1) of the Home Building Act). The same warranties are implied in a subcontract between a principal contractor and a subcontractor (s 18B(2)), which matters to a subcontractor whose work is defective or incomplete because the head contractor failed.
It is not the answer for every principal. The cover is confined to residential building work, a developer is excluded from its benefit (s 99(2) of the Home Building Act), and there is no equivalent fund for commercial or civil work. A commercial principal has no insurer to turn to, and that changes the shape of its position entirely: its recoveries are the security it holds, its rights under the contract and its payment claims, and its exposure is that the security may be the only money left in the project. That is why the security was analysed first, in Track two.
Before a claim is made, two limits matter. The benefit of the insurance runs to the person on whose behalf the work is done and their successors in title, and a developer is expressly excluded (s 99(2) of the Home Building Act). And where the required insurance was never in force, the contractor cannot enforce the contract or recover money for that work, including on a quantum meruit, except so far as a court or tribunal considers it just and equitable (s 94(1), (1A)). An uninsured contract therefore cuts both ways: it may leave the owner without cover, and it leaves the contractor without a remedy.
Example. A builder contracted to renovate a house becomes insolvent with the roof open and the frame incomplete. The owner has a certificate of insurance. The claim is for the cost of completing the work, up to the minimum cover of $340,000 per dwelling required by s 102(3) of the Home Building Act and cl 45 of the Home Building Regulation, and it is assessed against the policy rather than against the builder’s balance sheet. The builder’s liquidator is not a party to it. |
If the builder is eventually deregistered rather than left in liquidation, a further route opens. A person may recover from the insurer of a company that is deregistered an amount that was payable to the company under the insurance contract if the company had a liability to that person and the insurance contract covered that liability immediately before deregistration (s 601AG of the Corporations Act). It does not apply while the company still exists, which is why it is of no use during an administration or a liquidation; it is the provision that keeps a claim alive once there is no longer a defendant.
Adjudication: the SOP Act route survives administration
A payment claim made under the SOP Act is not extinguished by the respondent’s insolvency. A claimant serves a payment claim setting out the amount claimed and the construction work to which it relates (s 13), the respondent may reply with a payment schedule within the time allowed (s 14), and if the respondent does not pay the scheduled amount the claimant may recover it as a debt due (s 16).
Where the respondent fails to provide a payment schedule at all, the consequences are stronger: the respondent is not entitled to bring any cross-claim against the claimant, or to raise any defence in relation to matters arising under the construction contract, in proceedings to recover the unpaid portion of the claimed amount (s 15(4) of the SOP Act). That is why a subcontractor who served a payment claim and received nothing back is in a better position than one who accepted a verbal promise.
An adjudication determination can be enforced as a judgment debt by filing an adjudication certificate in a court of competent jurisdiction (s 25 of the SOP Act), which also expressly preserves the parties’ rights under the contract and at common law except to the extent the SOP Act provides otherwise (s 32). Attacking the determination itself is difficult — a determination is void only if the basic and essential requirements were not met, not merely because the adjudicator erred in law (Brodyn, in Key cases) — so in an insolvency the argument that matters is about enforcement, not validity.
The qualification that decides whether any of this is worth doing is the difference between administration and liquidation. While the company is under administration the regime keeps operating. Once it is in liquidation it does not: a corporation in liquidation cannot serve a payment claim, take any action under the SOP Act to enforce a payment claim or an adjudication determination, or apply for adjudication (s 32B(1)), and an adjudication application not finally determined immediately before the liquidation is taken to have been withdrawn on that day (s 32B(2)). Read s 32B precisely: it bars the company in liquidation from using the regime, so a builder that moves from administration into liquidation cannot pursue its own upstream claims against the principal. A subcontractor claiming against that builder is not barred by s 32B; what stops it is the winding-up stay in s 471B (or s 500(2) on a creditors’ voluntary winding up), and the court’s reluctance to allow an interim payment to be enforced against a company being wound up. That is why the claim and the adjudication certificate need to be in place before liquidation.
The interaction between the two regimes is therefore narrow but decisive: administration leaves the SOP Act route open, subject to consent or leave to enforce against the company (ss 440D and 471B of the Corporations Act), whereas liquidation bars a company in liquidation from using the SOP Act as claimant (s 32B) and stays enforcement against it as respondent (ss 471B, 500(2) of the Corporations Act). Practical sequencing, not principle, decides which route is worth the money.
Contractors Debts Act: the subcontractor’s route to the principal
New South Wales has a statutory mechanism with no direct equivalent in most other jurisdictions, and it is routinely missed. The Contractors Debts Act allows a subcontractor who is owed money by a defaulting contractor to claim that amount from the principal who owes the contractor.
The Act does not create the debt; it redirects one. A court may certify the debt only when judgment is given or entered up, which includes a judgment founded on an adjudication certificate filed under s 25 of the SOP Act (s 7(1), (1A) of the Contractors Debts Act). The sequence is therefore: get the adjudication, file the certificate, obtain the certificate of debt, then serve the notice. The subcontractor obtains certification of the debt by a court (s 7), serves a notice of claim on the principal, and the notice operates as an assignment of so much of the debt owed by the principal to the contractor as is necessary to discharge the subcontractor’s debt (s 8). The principal then pays the subcontractor instead of the contractor, and payment to the subcontractor discharges the principal’s liability to that extent (s 9). Assignments under the Contractors Debts Act have a priority regime of their own (s 10).
The practical value is that the principal may still be solvent and may still hold money for the defaulting contractor. The Contractors Debts Act reaches that money directly. It is a notice-driven remedy, so the timing and content of the notice, and the certification step before it, decide whether it is available at all.
Directors: the guarantee and insolvent trading routes
A claim against a director does not exist simply because the company failed. It requires a separate basis, and the most common is insolvent trading. A director contravenes s 588G of the Corporations Act if the company was insolvent at the time it incurred a debt, or became insolvent by incurring it, there were reasonable grounds for suspecting that the company was or would become insolvent, and the director was aware of those grounds or a reasonable person in a like position would have been.
The faster route is often a personal guarantee. Suppliers and subcontractors commonly extend credit on a director’s guarantee in the credit application, and a guarantee is a contractual obligation that does not depend on the company’s solvency, on proving insolvent trading, or on a liquidator’s decision to sue. If a guarantee was signed, read it before assuming the collapse leaves you with only a proof of debt. Two timing points matter: a deed of company arrangement or a liquidation does not release a director from a guarantee, but during the administration itself enforcement against a director is stayed without the leave of the court (s 440J of the Corporations Act).
For a builder continuing to incur subcontractor and supplier debts while insolvent, that provision — examined in detail in ASIC Regulatory Guide 217 — is the one to review, and it is a separate analysis on a separate clock from the proof of debt. It is also not the only route: the general directors’ duties and the voidable transaction provisions each have their own requirements.
What the administrator will ask you for
The administrator’s task is to identify the company’s assets and liabilities, and you will be asked to provide details of your claim and of any property of the company you hold. Failing to respond does not improve your position, and continuing to hold company property after a demand can create a liability of its own (s 483 of the Corporations Act).
Respond, but do not waive anything. A proof of debt records a claim for the purposes of s 553 of the Corporations Act; it does not settle it, and it does not release security. That distinction is worth holding to, because a proof of debt is routinely described in correspondence as though it concluded the matter, and it does not.
Time limits that do not stop for insolvency
The limitation clock keeps running through an external administration. An action on a simple contract must be brought within six years of the cause of action accruing (s 14 of the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW)); where the contract was executed as a deed, the period is twelve years (s 16). Statutory warranty claims under the Home Building Act run to their own periods, which are shorter. A principal or subcontractor who spends a year waiting on a liquidator can find that the claim against the one remaining solvent party — the insurer, the principal under the Contractors Debts Act, or a director — has expired in the meantime.
Where a claim is made directly against a liability insurer for the insured liability of a builder that has become insolvent, the Civil Liability (Third Party Claims Against Insurers) Act 2017 (NSW) permits recovery with the leave of the court (ss 4–5) subject to the insurer’s policy defences (s 7), and where an insured has died or cannot after reasonable inquiry be found, s 51 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) provides a separate direct-claim pathway — both worth checking before a claim is abandoned.
Key cases
Brodyn Pty Ltd t/as Time Cost and Quality v Davenport (2004) 61 NSWLR 421. An adjudicator’s determination is not open to attack for a non-jurisdictional error of law, and that core proposition has since been confirmed by the High Court in Probuild Constructions (Aust) Pty Ltd v Shade Systems Pty Ltd (2018) 264 CLR 1, which also confirmed that judicial review remains available for jurisdictional error and that a court may sever the affected part of a determination under s 32A of the SOP Act. It is valid if it complies with the basic and essential requirements the Court identified — a construction contract to which the SOP Act applies, service of a payment claim, an adjudication application to an authorised nominating authority, reference to an eligible adjudicator who accepts it, and a written determination of the amount payable — provided the adjudicator made a bona fide attempt to exercise the power and there was no substantial denial of natural justice. A purported determination that fails those requirements is void, not merely voidable.
How Merlo Law can help
Merlo Law advises NSW principals and subcontractors when a builder or head contractor becomes insolvent mid-project, and works through the three tracks together because the decisions affect each other. Reading the contract in isolation misses the insurance; pursuing the insurance in isolation misses the payment claim, which is often faster and sometimes larger.
We act through our commercial law advice team, and where payment claims are involved, provide security of payment advice. Where the contract has to be terminated and the works completed, the relevant experience is in our building and construction disputes work. If the position has already produced a statutory demand, the deadlines are fixed and cannot be extended — see what happens if the 21-day deadline is missed and what it costs to fight or set aside a statutory demand. To have the position assessed before further steps are taken, contact Merlo Law. The first creditors’ meeting must be held within 8 business days of the administration beginning, so the practical window is shorter than most principals and subcontractors expect.
Conclusion
A mid-project insolvency is a cash and sequencing problem before it is a legal one. Secure the site in accordance with the contract, stop the money, and identify the claims that outlive the company — the policy, the payment right, the statutory assignment, and where it exists, the director.
Everything else is a proof of debt, and a proof of debt in a small construction company is worth very little. The mistake is spending the first fortnight on the claim that will return the least.
FAQs
What are my options if my builder becomes insolvent mid-project?
Secure the site, stop further payment, and identify the claims that survive — the Home Building Act insurance, statutory warranty entitlements, payment rights under the SOP Act, and any claim against the principal under the Contractors Debts Act — alongside your position under the contract.
Can I terminate the contract and engage someone else?
Usually, if the contract permits it and the default and termination provisions have been satisfied. Acting before that point creates a wrongful termination risk, and an administrator controls the company’s business and property in the meantime (s 437A of the Corporations Act).
Should I keep paying the builder?
No. Do not pay the builder after an administrator or liquidator is appointed without written terms agreed with the external administrator. An overpayment already made is an unsecured claim, admissible to proof only if the circumstances giving rise to it occurred before the relevant date (s 553(1) of the Corporations Act). Section 9 fixes that date as the day the winding up is taken to have begun under Division 1A of Part 5.6, which is not necessarily the day of the appointment, so whether a particular payment sits inside or outside the proof regime depends on how the company is wound up. A payment the builder made to a creditor shortly before the appointment may itself be recoverable by a liquidator as an unfair preference (ss 588FA, 588FE).
Can I claim against the director personally?
Not simply because the company failed. A claim against a director requires a separate basis, most commonly insolvent trading under s 588G of the Corporations Act, or a personal guarantee signed in a credit application — the fastest route, because it does not depend on proving insolvency or on a liquidator suing. Either should be assessed on its own footing and its own limitation period.
Does my home building insurance cover the builder going broke?
That is precisely what it is required to cover. Where residential building work was insured as required, the policy must insure the owner against loss from non-completion caused by the contractor’s insolvency, and against the inability to have a statutory warranty rectified or to recover compensation because of that insolvency (s 99(1) of the Home Building Act).
This guide is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For advice tailored to your specific circumstances, please contact Merlo Law








Comments